The Seattle Seahawks acquired their leading sacker for 2010, Chris Clemons, from the Philadelphia Eagles one year ago Tuesday.
They acquired their backup quarterback and potential future starter, Charlie Whitehurst, from San Diego one year ago Wednesday.
By this time in 2010, the Arizona Cardinals had traded receiver Anquan Boldin, lost Antrel Rolle and Karlos Dansby in free agency, acquired safety Kerry Rhodes from the New York Jets and signed linebacker Paris Lenon, among other moves.
This March, we hear only crickets as the NFL lockout prevents teams from making roster transactions of any kind. The quiet period has shifted our football-related energies to the draft, which the league intends to operate pretty much as normal.
While draft classes can take multiple years to fully assess, free-agent crops tend to produce more immediate results, for better or worse. Let’s take a look back at what NFC West teams got — and still might get — from their wheeling and dealing last offseason.
2010 unrestricted free agency
Best UFA signing: Fred Robbins, defensive tackle, St. Louis Rams.
Coach Steve Spagnuolo reached into his past with the New York Giants in seeking a needed upgrade to the Rams’ defensive interior. Robbins outplayed the three-year deal he signed averaging $3.75 million per season.
Robbins started 16 games and collected a career-high six sacks for a defense that outperformed expectations. His presence on the line helped defensive ends Chris Long and James Hall produce at a higher level.
Worst UFA signing: David Carr, quarterback, San Francisco 49ers.
The 49ers signed Carr and traded backup Shaun Hill in an effort to upgrade the position, but when they needed Carr to play, coach Mike Singletary gave him virtually no chance. Carr finished up the Carolina game before Singletary turned to third-stringer Troy Smith to start while Alex Smith recovered from injury.
It’s tough to fault Carr much for what was, by all accounts, a messed-up situation. The 49ers’ general manager, Scot McCloughan, left the organization shortly after the team acquired Carr. The team changed offensive coordinators early in the season. Singletary didn’t know how to handle quarterbacks.
Conclusion: NFC West teams signed relatively few UFAs last offseason, in part because new rules prevented players with fewer than six accrued seasons from hitting the market. Jay Feely, Paris Lenon and Rex Hadnot signed with Arizona. Robbins and A.J. Feeley signed with the Rams. Ben Hamilton and Sean Morey signed with Seattle. Carr and William James signed with the 49ers.
2010 additions by trade
Best acquisition: Chris Clemons, defensive end, Seahawks
Seattle and Philadelphia seemed to be swapping spare parts when the Seahawks sent Darryl Tapp to the Eagles for Clemons.
Neither player had reached his potential previously.
Clemons set career highs with 11 sacks and 16 starts while filling the “Leo” position in coach Pete Carroll’s defense. Tapp had three sacks and one start for the Eagles, making this deal a clear “win” for Seattle.
The Seahawks also received a fifth-round choice in return from the Eagles, but the player they selected with the choice, defensive end E.J. Wilson, was released during the season.
Worst acquisition: Stacy Andrews, guard, Seahawks.
The Seahawks could still come out OK on this one. The team had Andrews in mind as a candidate to play tackle in 2011, and that could still happen. But Andrews wasn’t effective enough as a starting guard to stay in the lineup even though Seattle had serious manpower problems on its offensive line.
Perhaps Seattle can put Andrews to better use in 2011.
Conclusion: Charlie Whitehurst could have made the “worst” list for Seattle because he hardly played even though quarterback was a trouble spot, but his performance in Week 17 carried Seattle into the playoffs. He could still validate the trade. Ted Ginn Jr. was a disappointment as a wide receiver for the 49ers, but injuries and quarterback instability contributed. Ginn upgraded the return game. NFC West teams fared well in acquiring Leon Washington, Kerry Rhodes and Mark Clayton. Marshawn Lynch’s memorable run against New Orleans in the playoffs made that deal look better.
2010 subtractions by trade
Best subtraction: Alex Barron, tackle, from the Rams.
St. Louis got nothing of lasting value in return for Barron, but the penalty-prone tackle was not missed. Rookie Rodger Saffold stepped in at left tackle and outperformed reasonable expectations for a rookie. Barron’s time in St. Louis had run its course. The team was taking a risk with its depth by dumping Barron for linebacker Bobby Carpenter, who did not stick on the roster, but the move worked out well from the Rams’ perspective.
Worst subtraction: Rob Sims, guard, from the Seahawks.
Seattle’s thinking on the offensive line seemed disjointed.
Line coach Alex Gibbs retired a week before the season, changing the qualities Seattle valued in its linemen. Gibbs preferred smaller linemen, particularly guards. Sims was a solid starter, but he didn’t fit the Gibbs profile. Seattle sent Sims and a seventh-round choice to Detroit for Robert Henderson, who did not earn a roster spot. The Seahawks also landed a fifth-round choice, used for strong safety Kam Chancellor.
The Seahawks used 11 starting combinations on their offensive line last season, and every one of them would have been better with Sims at left guard. Sims started 16 games for the Lions and played well, by all accounts. His presence in Seattle would have allowed the team to get more from Lynch in the ground game.
Conclusion: The trade that subtracted Boldin from the Cardinals might have qualified under different circumstances, but the time had come for Arizona to part with the exceptional wideout. The team picked up a third-round choice as partial compensation, a pick used for promising receiver Andre Roberts. The 49ers get mention here for the deal that sent Hill to Detroit and cleared the way for Carr’s signing. Hill had a 10-6 record as a starter for San Francisco. Even if he wasn’t the answer long term, he would have give the team better options in 2010. NFC West teams also parted with Deion Branch, Lawrence Jackson, Josh Wilson, Adam Carriker and Kentwan Balmer, among others, by trade last offseason.
Looking to the future
NFL teams remain unsettled from a roster standpoint while they wait for a labor resolution of some kind.
The Rams are the only NFC West team without serious question marks at quarterback. Lingering questions at that position will hang over the 49ers, Cardinals and Seahawks while the lockout continues.
Getting a new collective bargaining agreement in place before the draft would help those teams more than others by clearing the way for them to pursue veteran passers. Otherwise, these teams could feel extra pressure to address the position in the draft — a difficult predicament given the hit-and-miss nature of quarterback evaluation in general.